Fro's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Skela - Mighty]

Hmm.

You have this in the General Rock genre, but I think it's more techno than it is rock. I know that you made it a mix of both, but just from listening to it I get more techno than anything. Anyway the song was pretty cool. Very fast beat and up tempo. It was a lot of fun to listen too. It really does deserve a ten in my opinion. Here is another submission where I liked the fadeout at the end, which isn't very often because I don't really like the fadeou too much. I liked it on this song though. This would be great for a fast action flash animation.

C52

~ Review Request Club ~

Skela responds:

Big thanks for the review!

[<==Stomp the Sand==>]

Not bad.

I enjoyed most of the audio submission here up to around the 1 minute part, where I did find it to be a little messy. It kind of sounded like there were too many things going on at once for about 10 seconds there. Other than that the submission was alright. I loved how the song ended on the final note. I enjoy songs that end like this much more than the songs that play through or fade out.

C52

~ Review Request Club ~

DjCompass responds:

Thanks, i'm glad you mostly liked it. This isn't one of my best submissions, so i duly note that you're right, there are too many voices for a bit, and other than that, thanks for the review.

[TransAmbient Loop]

I liked this loop.

Maybe just a tad bit longer would help it out, but with what you had you still had a lot of variety in such a little piece of audio. It doesn't really loop perfectly though, there is a little bit of space between the ending and the beginning. The more and more that I listened to it though the harder it was to tell. Maybe make it so it loops just a tad bit better I guess.

C52

~ Review Request Club ~

jxl180 responds:

Yeah, for some reason the first time around there is a space for some reason, but after that it loops almost perfectly.

[[LY] ,-Mayosun-']

Not too bad.

It does loop very nicely together, but I think that if you added just a little bit of "something" that just mixed it up a little and added a little bit of variety somewhere in the middle of the song that it would make this much more enjoyable. Not only that, but it would make it so it wouldn't get as boring as quickly because it would take a little longer to loop around the second time. Not bad though I can see this being used as background music in a flash game.

C52

~ Review Request Club ~

[rock song?]

Rock?

Well this might be rock, but I'm just not sure yet. :P It needs to be much longer for me to really tell. I will say that what you had though wasn't too bad, but still needs some work. I can live with the beginning, but towards the end it might have just gotten a little too sloppy and messy. I think that you almost have it on the right track though. The first impression that I got from the music was that it might be a decent short sound track for an introduction of a boss or enemy in a flash game/movie.

C52

~ Review Request Club ~

[(FMC) -=Sudden Death=-]

Nice job.

Very upbeat and very fast tempo during the entire song. There was a lot of variety and I really enjoyed listening to the submission. The submission had good length to it and I could probably listen to it through a couple of times before I got bored with it. I have to admit though that the ending would of probably been better with some sort of indication that it was over instead of just the notes continuing through the ending. Maybe some sort of fade out, even though I'm not a fan of fade outs, or have the song end on a series of notes. Other than that though a very good submission.

C52

~ Review Request Club ~

FunkmasterCatking responds:

Thanks for the review!

[TransAmbience]

Pretty cool.

The thing is I just don't know if the two genres do mix together well, but if they can you kind of got off to the right start here. After listening to the song you really get the meaning of the title. Would of this have been better with a transition? I really don't know. I guess I would have to hear it that way to figure it out, but this way didn't really bother me too much. I thought if ran together alright. I see at the end where you got the idea from Little Foot. Overall pretty good.

C52

~ Review Request Club ~

jxl180 responds:

Thanks for your review and suggestions.

jxl180

[HungHimselfWithAGuitarString]

Just like you said.

Just like you said in your author comments it was just a bit sloppy and the quality wasn't the best either. It has that effect of you kind of just throwing it together if you know what I mean. Not the best, but I don't think you really "sucked" at the guitar or drums at all. Some of this did sound really good, but it just sounded like some of it didn't fit with the other parts. Anyway, just tidy it up a little bit and if at all possible get rid of the sloppy effect that you have created here. The part that you added at 1:40 (I think that is the right time) was a pretty awesome part though.

C52

~ Review Request Club ~

SymbolCymbal responds:

thank you corky.
i really should get this back into logic studios and fix it up somewhat. Being that im kinda lazy when it comes to this song is a prob though. Alot of the part just seem to jump into eachother with a bad mix.
i have been getting pretty good reviews which i am surprised about.
thanks for the comments ... ill be using them when i remake this song.. which might take a lil bit of time.

[Paper Mario - Tutankoopa]

Nice job!

I've never played Paper Mario or heard of it for that matter, but this song was pretty cool. It was definitely different for sure. Did you pretty much make it a remake as a song from the game or was it more your own creation? Either way pretty good job with this man. There isn't much more to say about it.

C52

~ Review Request Club ~

ninjakoopa-33 responds:

This was pretty much my own creation.
As sirtom93 said, it's very much different from the original. If you were to listen to the original, then compare to this track, you can see a big difference.
Anyways, thanks for the review!