Fro's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Desolate Symphony]

Very nice.

This was a great submission. Very relaxing and enjoyable. It really reminded me of a song that would be heard in the Final Fantasy games. Probably one that would be used in a sad scene.

That being said, this would probably be a great piece of audio to use in a flash that needed a song to a sad scene. I can imagine the after math of a battle scene where almost everyone is dead and somebody is holding another person in their arms just wondering why it had to be them.

An overall great submission. I think I just may add it to my favorites.

~ Review Request Club ~

jxl180 responds:

Thank you so much! Come to think of it, I believe you added my other classical song (Tragedy at Dawn) to your favorites, as well. lol

[[S:C] Gigantic Pentameter]

Very relaxing.

This song was actually very relaxing to listen to. I don't know how long I let it play, but I at least let it play over about 5 times while surfing around on the BBS and everything.

You can really hear the old school hip hop in this submission. I don't know what else you could really do to this submission to make it better because personally myself I rather enjoyed the way it sounded. Also, I don't know anything about music. :P

Sounds like it would be pretty good for credits of a submission. All around good song. (the reviews below me are huge D:)

~ Review Request Club ~

SymbolCymbal responds:

True to your form corky. You never let me down for a review. even when the request club has seen better times.

Im very glad you enjoyed this little piece.. i guess every musician always wants to create an atmosphere or and image or even just a slight feeling when someone listened to a creation.
Im very glad i had made a placid moment for you.

[Backing Force]

Nice job.

This was quite an interesting song to listen to. In my opinion it's much better than most trance songs that are on the website. It almost sounds like it has bits and pieces of video game music in there. Or at least I do get a bit of a video game feeling out of it.

It's not too repetitive and you have a bit of variety in this submission, which makes it interesting to listen to. An all around good song that is worth listening too. Good job.

~ Review Request Club ~

Sawdust responds:

Thanks for the advice, I honestly didn't even expect a review.

[MCC]

Hmm, you really really suck at this.

Nah, I'm just joking. ;) Good job. Sometimes it doesn't sound like it's the best quality, but I really did enjoy listening to this. Perhaps good credit music for a submission? PERHAPS good credit music for our Madness Day submission also.

Maybe even something like when the car full of swat guys drives in during the beginning. Probably better for the credits like I said though.

I see that it was suppose to loop, but instead I wouldn't mind seeing it being about 10 to 20 seconds longer with a fade out at the end. (Kind of like what you would want for credits of a submission, but that's just me being hell bent with this being the most useful for credits)

The song itself has a nice upbeat sound to it. Maybe even a sound that suggest that there is something wrong or dangerous ahead, but nothing is going to stop you even if it is dangerous.

Decent job all around. Anytime you ever submit something drop me a PM or something and I'll review it.

AntiAliasProductionz responds:

Thanks. It was actually meant to sound REALLY distorted, but I had to turn it down a notch. I was gonna do something with it. But whatever. Thanks for the review.

[Jxl180 - Tranquility]

Alright.

I approached this one differently. I listened to it about two or three times and really didn't like the way that it sounded. I then let it play about ten times through while lurking the BBS and voting on some submissions and noticed that it really does sound pretty good.

It has this sort of calming affect and is really relaxing to listen too. It also has a very dreamy feeling to it like your floating off into space while sleeping. Really not a bad song at all and I recommend to people song carefully.

~ Review Request Club ~

jxl180 responds:

Thank you! And that was exactly what I was going for! Not a song that keeps repeating with a set pattern, but one that flows through in a relaxing way. Also I wanted the song to progress, so I made it not repeat like a traditional song. Thank you for really taking the time to listen to it!

jxl180

[Battle of the crossed plants 4]

Hmm

I didn't like this one as much, but for some reason I still like it more than most of your other submissions and I am feeling generous today so here is another 8 from me.

The one thing about this is I just found it as a very generic sound. It wasn't anything too interesting to listen to. Kind of upbeat, but like I said nothing that really makes me interested.

I don't think it looped the best, but it was pretty damn close to being a great loop. It was off by just a little bit. Probably just the space newgrounds puts between its songs.

~ Review Request Club ~

[blank through]

Woah woah woah

I liked this one also. Perhaps it's just me today, but I don't think I've ever given your submissions scores this high. I really love the randomness of this submission. It almost sounds like a robot is in a battle and then all of the sudden he shuts down, tries to boot back up, shuts back down, etc... In an endless loop.

This one was really interesting and had a great original sound to it. Really random and weird, which can be a good things sometimes. Good job.

~ Review Request Club ~

[pianoforte in a minor]

Beautiful loop.

You can't loop this any better than what you did here. By far the best quality loop I have heard of yours. I know it was a perfect loop because I pulled up a different tab while listening to this and had no clue that it was repeating.

I could see it being used in a spooky haunted house scene in a flash animation for a small scene. Nothing too long because after about 10 listens it does get kind of annoying. :p It's like that with almost every loop though.

Great job in my opinion though. One of your best loops that I have seen to this day.

~ Review Request Club ~

mikkim responds:

thanks for the review.

[.:Guitar Electricity Loop:.]

Not too bad.

It has a nice upbeat sound to it. It just really sounds like you used a lot of premade loops here. Well I know you at least used a couple since I've personally heard some of them in garage band before. If you didn't you really made them sound similar.

Towards the end of the song it sounds a bit choppy and the quality of the song goes downhill a little bit. In some parts it sounded like you cut the premade loops off at a bad spot. Making transitions a little bit more smoother may help it out. The beginning to the song was definitely the best part, but after that it really wasn't too great to listen too in my opinion.

~ Review Request Club ~

kchrules responds:

Thank you

[Unamed Legend - WIP]

Another good song.

Looks like I've been running into a lot of good songs lately in the Review Request Club. I like how the song starts off slow pace and sad and slowly builds up a little bit. It still has a sad sound to it even though the song has picked up a little bit.

The length of the submission was pretty good and you had a pretty good assortment of variety throughout the song. It never really got boring. It had a nice use of sound effects.

The only thing that I can think of is that the ending just kind of sneaks up on you. It just kind of ends all of a sudden and to me it really doesn't sound like it should end where it did. Perhaps a series of notes that better resemble an ending or perhaps a fade out would work too. I rather the song end on a note, but to me it sounded like this was out of nowhere.

Other than that good job on the song.

~ Review Request Club ~

TheBellmaker responds:

Thanks for the review. The ending wasn't really supposed to be and ending, but I forgot to mention it in the description. Thanks for listening to my song.