Fro's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Oasis Split Up Song #1]

~ Review Request Club ~

The overall feel that I got from the submission was that you may have let things get a bit repetitive by allowing the same thing to happen over and over for a bit to long, but the song itself isn't repetitive as it changes up many times.

I mean more as the same sounds are happening for a tad too long in the song before you change it up. Probably taking 10 seconds off of the submission in a whole could help this a little bit, but it still wasn't terrible. I just knew that when I listened to it I was on the verge of saying "This is too repetitive in this part" a couple of times, but shortly after the thought entered my head the song seemed to change up a bit.

I do like the part around 3:25 give or take a few seconds. I thought that was the best part in the song. I also think that you set it up to be better with vocals, but it's alright without them as well.

~ Review Request Club ~

Sawdust responds:

Why are all my songs repetitive? Oh well, it's fine, i'll make adjustments then.

Thanks.

[[G] The Battlefield ft. Gent G]

~ Review Request Club ~

Not my type of music, but I actually rather enjoyed this submission. The strong points had to be not only the good instruments and what seemed to be the perfect lyrics, but more of how they went so well together and that they mixed really good. The talking in the beginning was also very fitting. It almost seems like something you would hear during a war.

The vocals for the rest of the song weren't bad, but could have been better. When I hear them I just think that there should be more emotion behind them. It's almost like the person singing here is just going through the motions and not really getting that into it. Other than that, good intro and an all around decent song.

~ Review Request Club ~

Jirohbomb responds:

First of all, I GOT A REVIEW!!! OH HAPPY DAY!!! Second of all, I chose this beat because it has the feel of a battle going on. I wanted that feel to be obvious so I did that intro to tell a story in a way. my friend and I worked hard on the lyrics, but not on recording (he didn't I did) because he had only one shot at recording because he was getting picked up by his mom so he had to hurry up. Since this was our first try at recording, we didn't have all the expertise to make this be the best song ever. Thank you for the review, and I'll be sure to come back to the Review Request Club because you guys are freaking awesome at reviewing.

[[G] When Giants Clash (Ins.)]

~ Review Request Club ~

I just listened to the song before reading your author comments and the only feeling that I really got from the submission was that it was done very well, but only if it were made for vocals to go over it.

If it wasn't made for vocals to go over it then I would say it was a tad bit too simple and got a little bit repetitive after awhile. But with vocals this would take away from the repetitive nature a bit and it would make it much more satisfying to the ear. Other than that there isn't much to fix. By itself it's too repetitive, but I think the vocals will fix that up pretty good.

~ Review Request Club ~

Jirohbomb responds:

It was meant for vocals, (which is taking longer than I thought) and I am still working on the vocals. Thank you for the review.

[All Hail Windows! 2]

~ Review Request Club ~

I've actually seen it done every now and then, but honestly never as good as this one was done. So original concept? Perhaps not to someone who's seen it done a bit, but creative approach and best execution that I've seen.

Love the creative nature in this and I can't even start to imagine what it takes to write something like this. For someone that is good with music as yourself it might not be so hard, but for someone like me I don't think I could ever make something like this.

I wouldn't say the ending was creative as anyone who has half a brain would use that as an ending. :P The thing is it still sounded great that you did it and it shouldn't have ended any other way.

~ Review Request Club ~

Step responds:

Wow, thanks for the compliments. I had this idea in my mind since I was about 7, and after hearing other people do it on NG about a year ago, I started giving it a try.
Oh, and I spot a mistake in your review. I'm not really good with music :P. I've only used FL Studio for about half a year or less. Making Windows songs sound as good as this is just sheer luck ;)
Still, thanks anyway, I'm glad you enjoyed the song XD.

[Coconut - Original Redux]

~ Review Request Club ~

Lol what?

I love how this sounds like it would be some cheesy love song before you even get to the lyrics. Then the lyrics just made me say, "What the fuck is this?" Ha, the lyrics were awesome and really made me laugh a lot. (couple bonus points)

Good guitar all around. I love how genres switch as it goes to some general soft rock to random hip hop. The vocals themselves weren't very good though. Very poor quality with a lot of static/interference behind them. Not the best of singing as well, but the main thing about the vocals was the quality of them.

~ Review Request Club ~

DumbassDude responds:

Thanks Fro :3

I am a pretty shitty singer and I was using a rock band microphone, ha.

[Jungle Rythm]

~ Review Request Club ~

Ah, so long to listen to. O.o

This was a very long song and I do think it could be a bit shorter to keep the attention of smaller minded users, but it never got too repetitive or anything of the sort so it wasn't bad like that.

Nice build up effects used every now and then. Pretty good title to the submission as the drums remind me of a jungle even though I haven't ever seen one in person. ;) I actually thought the song was going to end somewhere around 5:10 seconds.

If you were to ever shorten it I would say take out something before 5:10 seconds because right before the 5 minute mark and the rest of the song was probably my favorite part.

An all around good song. Enjoyed listening to it from the beginning to the end.

~ Review Request Club ~

Step responds:

Thanks for the helpful review. I tried to make it as long as possible since I made one other (and I have another ready to submit), and those are pretty short, so I kind of made this one as a grand finale :D. I'm glad you liked from 5:10 onwards, it's the first time I tried a key change which actually came out OK. Thanks for the compliments and I'm happy you enjoyed it :D.

[Taxmurder]

~ Review Request Club ~

Very catchy beat all around and it's a pretty fun submission to listen to. Perhaps a bit repetitive every now and then, but you did change it up a little bit here and there to make it manageable.

Perhaps some vocals or faded voices saying something would sound pretty cool. I think something like a count down from 3 or a count up from 3 in a voice would sound pretty cool. Something along the lines of, "1, 2, 3, Go."

I do think that the ending was a little abrupt and that there could have been a build up to the ending or a better series of notes to end it on than what you used.

~ Review Request Club ~

Sawdust responds:

Indeed, it was too sudden, I didn't exactly elaborate on the ending sequence. So, i'll probably throw in a synth there coming in ocassionally, and coming in at the end and punctuating the song.

[[LY] DNB [Demoupdate]]

~ Review Request Club ~

Good job all around. I was thinking about taking some off for the way the voice interrupts in the beginning, but I decided not to. It should really go in the beginning or at least it'll make the song better if you did that in my opinion.

Very original sound to this all around. Doesn't sound generic or anything, which can be hard to come by. Set it up perfect and I can't really see anyway how to improve this in anyway. (probably since I don't know the techy stuff about music)

Pretty good all around like I said. Original sound to it and a very catchy beat. Worth a listen to so check it out people. ;)

~ Review Request Club ~

la-yinn responds:

Haha, thanks a lot Fro! ^_^

[Hardcore, thats right]

~ Review Request Club ~

Very catchy. I'll jump on the band wagon and say that the submission was very catchy with the first part of my review. :P Some generic sound to it as it does have a lot of traces of many other trance songs, but there isn't a genre that doesn't do that so I can't complain.

Very good quality, great mixing all around. I loved the use of voices in the submission. They really sounded good and it's cool how they matched the title of the submission and everything. The title of the submission makes me laugh a little bit to be honest. :P

I think perhaps you could have had a males voice saying, "Hardcore" somewhere in the song to really match the title could have been cool. It might make it worse, but it might be interesting to see how it sounds.

~ Review Request Club ~

DeejayDeeZ responds:

Nice, thanks alot for giving me a 10 :D.

Yeah, there is some generic sounds, but whatever. The song itself is not that generic I hope... ^^

Hahaha, your one of the few ones that like the voices, but thats cool. And I couldnt come up with a fitting name to this song, so I based it on the voices, lol.

A male voice saying, Hardcore? Haha, in my imagination that dosent sound quite good. But yeah, maybee I should check how it fits.

Thanks again for your good review.

-Deejay DeeZ

[As of yet unnamed]

~ Review Request Club ~

Hm, I'm no professional at music, but some things sounded a bit off tune. If so then it's just my ears telling me so and if not like I said I'm not a professional, but I'm just following what my ears tell me.

For the most part the guitar sounds pretty good all around. Some parts didn't seem to fit every now and then, but the overall feel that I get from the guitar is pretty good.

I noticed the static part in the beginning and I wasn't sure if that was suppose to be rain or static, but I just assume it's static. Perhaps that's just a recording equipment problem or something of the sort.

~ Review Request Club ~

mistermurfi responds:

yeah had a dodgy cable when i recorded it so it is just static

parts will sound out of place in most things i record because i generally do it on the improv with no pre thoughts on what to play sometimes it works sometimes not but hey thats what musics about right?

again thanks for the review :D