Fro's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Arecibo Theme Song (Ver. 2)]

Well.

I liked it better then the first one, it seems after reading some of the reviews that I am one of few that did. I noticed that you said this was made first and then the other one was made second? That def. doesn't make any sense in titling then. Shouldn't you name this one version 1 and that one version 2? Anyway, this one had what the other one didn't have and that is length. If the other one had been longer then I would of given it a better score. I should of given it a lower rating now that I think about it, around a 6. This one deserves an 8 though even border line 9.

C52

~ Review Request Club ~

BreakingFaces responds:

Thanks, it was version two because version one is the one I'll use for the main title sequence.

[Arecibo Theme Song (Ver. 1)]

Well.

Everything that was there is great, I can't say anything wrong with it at all so you don't get a low rating because of that, but this is what I don't really understand. You say "Don't review or rate unless you've listened to the entire piece." Is that even possible? It's only 35 seconds long they would almost have to listen to most of it by the time that they reviewed it and even a little bit of it before the voted on it. Way to short even for a theme song. Theme songs should be a little longer then 35 seconds in my opinion.

C52

~ Review Request Club ~

BreakingFaces responds:

For a flash cartoon, and the attention span of most NG users, I had to make the theme song around 30 seconds.

[Menu²]

Not bad.

If I ever got into making a lot of flash movies then I wouldn't mind using something similar to this. It loops nicely, but I think that just a bit more variety would of been better. That shouldn't matter too much though since a menu wouldn't be on screen long enough to make someone think that it's too repetitive. Good job.

C52

loogiesquared responds:

>=U
i never LET you use this! ;)

[FF8 - Man With The Machine Gun]

Yes.

This was def. Final Fantasy material my dear friend. This really makes me sad kind of though because games like these were absolutely my favorite and I have either lost them all, don't own them anymore, or just don't have time for them anymore. To bad though because they are awesome. You hit this right on the spot. Keep up the great work.

C52

~ Review Request Club ~

[Tragedy at Dawn]

I loved it.

I'm always looking for creepy stuff like this on newgrounds for some future flash that will be being made. This means if you don't mind then I may use your audio in the next year or two. (Big projects, taking a long time). It's perfect ambient music and also wouldn't be bad in the genre. Great job and keep up the great work. I added it as a favorite so I can come back to it in the future.

C52

~ Review Request Club ~

jxl180 responds:

I would be honored if my song is used in a Flash Submission!

Thank you for the consideration, review, and favorite!

[Drums of Doom! (DjD)]

Not bad.

I'm impressed that throughout the entire drum solo that you didn't use and preset music at all. That must of took a little bit of time to make. This is a great drum solo, which was great all the way through and ended really heavy and fast like I was hoping that it would. You should think about adding guitar to these and see what the outcome would be. It may be a pretty good song.

C52

~ Review Request Club ~

Mad-Muppet responds:

Thanks for the great review! Too bad I can't play the guitar :P

[-_>Fleeting Dreams<_- [old]]

Not bad.

It was pretty good throughout the entire song, but the ending just sounded really out of place. It really sounds like you should of continued along with it instead of having it end there. That noise that is at the end just makes it sound like it ends abruptly. Not too bad though. It could use a bit of variety here and there. Maybe just one more instrument would of made it, but it would still be fine without the extra instrument.

C52

MaestroAndante responds:

And again, I'm fairly new to this. I'll add a bit more next time. Thanks for the review.

[** \Guitar Challenge - So]

U R My God.

Ha, that was an awesome solo. It looks like someone reviewed Corky52's theme saying that there should of been a solo added at the end of the song. I don't think it's a bad idea. Maybe it could be added to the one that you may add vocals to. I don't think this solo would sound good added to it though. I like around 25 seconds where the solo is really fast. I love solos that are fast like that, but I also which that they would last longer. Like how the solo in One is crazy long and fast as hell. It wouldn't have to be that long of course, but several more seconds would make it fun to listen to. Keep up the great work that you are doing with your audio.

C52

Sonofkirk responds:

Thanks for the review Corky : ). I will remake your theme with some vocals (I will ask Bad Man) and with a longer and faster solo lol.
\m/

[<--Heaven and Earth-->]

Hmmm..

I also have to clue how you constructed it, but I get this feeling that I have heard a different version of this audio somewhere. I get the feeling that I had either played a game with a version of this song, heard it somewhere on a movie or tv, or maybe even heard it somewhere on another newgrounds audio submission. It could also be that I listened to it once or twice several days ago and never got to writing the review until now also. I found that the submission was almost the perfect length and that it never really got boring or repetitive. It was a fun submission to listen to. Good job.

C52

~ Review Request Club ~

DjCompass responds:

Glad you liked it. You might've heard a similar song, that happens. But all my music is original, no remixes or anything (not yet anyways...). I also try to make sure it's not repetitive, so i'm glad to see that effort is paying off ^^
Glad you enjoyed it, thanks for the review.

[Forgotten Love]

Good job.

This was pretty good all around. The only reason it didn't get a higher rating from me is because of the length of the submission was very short. If this was turned into a longer submission then it probably would of gotten the full ten from me. I always love hearing the piano in audio submissions on newgrounds and this time around it really makes the song. Good job.

C52

~ Review Request Club ~