Fro's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[ECHO - Sons of Scotland (]

~ Review Request Club ~

You won't have to worry about me even coming close to reaching the character limit on an audio review ever. :P Even though I've done it in flash reviews I don't know anything techy about music so mine are sadly just some short opinions here and there.

The song sounds very patriotic. It sounds like something you would listen to/play if you were very proud of being Scottish or living in Scotland. Perhaps something you would play in a celebration or something of the sort.

The instruments of course make it sound like a Scottish song and it almost sounds like something you could expect to hear from a marching band during a parade or something of the sort. It's very realistic sounding like I would hear it in real life.

An all around good song!

~ Review Request Club ~

[mik // the beach \\]

~ Review Request Club ~

I almost thought that the song was a bit too happy and that the waves were a bit too dark. They almost sounded dangerous or something lol. Anyway, I would stick with the theme of the song. Very happy, but maybe tune it down a bit as it did get very "busy" in some parts of the song. (more towards the end)

There was a lot of variety though and you couldn't really ever get bored with this song. Great use of sound effects as well! An alright song all around.

~ Review Request Club ~

[Come on lets Go!]

~ Review Request Club ~

I enjoyed this submission a lot! It almost sounded like a hardcore sonic song for some reason. I haven't even played sonic since the old school Sega game so I don't know why it reminded me of that. O.o

Very fast and in your face. It almost starts off like it's heavy metal, but sort of calms down later. Unlike your other submission I reviewed this one has much better quality! It probably doesn't get much better than that actually.

I do wish that you would continue this and make it longer though. It does sound great the way it is, but it sounded really good and I just kind of wanted it to continue. Keep up the good work though. :)

~ Review Request Club ~

sicjes responds:

Thanks for the review. I tried really hard to make this the best quality I could and with every song I do I learn a bit more and a few new tricks. I am glad you like, It is short and in your face, I had written it to enter in a conest for t.v. so it had to be short and to the point. But it is my work so I am currently working it in to a real song with vocals all that. Thanks again

[[LY] Afternoon Blazing [D]]

~ Review Request Club ~

I probably listened to this song 2 and a half times, probably more like 3 and a half after I'm done writing this review. It was very relaxing and something that you can really just sit back and calm down.

Like you've said to make this better I would add a bit to it. It was a bit simple and didn't really have a lot going on at any given time. It also gets a bit repetitive so adding some variety would help a lot. Looks like you already know what to do to make it better, but as it is now it's a very calm and relaxing song.

~ Review Request Club ~

la-yinn responds:

Thanks for the compliments Fro, I really appreciate the review. I will be making a full version, probably have it up by next weekend. :-)

[itookachillpill]

~ Review Request Club ~

This is a very relaxing song. Not very complex or anything, but enjoyable to listen to all around. I personally don't see anything wrong with it, but perhaps it's a bit too simple?

You did a wonderful job of creating a song that would be great with vocals so I think that's how you could improve on this submission. I don't know how your singing skills are, but it really doesn't matter as an acoustic song like this doesn't really need the best vocals to still sound good.

~ Review Request Club ~

loansindi responds:

Thanks for the review!

I'm hoping to get vocals on this track. They likely won't be my own, I'm not much of a singer. We'll see.

[\m/_Human Catastrophe_\m/]

Nice job man

So I'm assuming you added vocals to this song? The song itself was done very well so props to deathkllr84 on making a good base. I'll have to check out some of his other stuff sometime because it seems very good.

The vocal sound awesome man! Some of the best on the website. Great vocals and great lyrics. Looks like you've done your job quite nicely.

Also, I always thought you had more songs... what happened? Anyway, going right to my favorites. Great job.

XxCRUCIFIEDxX responds:

deathkllr84 is awesome. It is well worth listening to all his tracks. Very insane. Thanks for listening and the props, I did have more songs and will have them back up it's just taking longer than expected to redo all of em

\m/ HAIL! \m/

[Final Days]

~ Review Request Club ~

The quality really takes away a lot of enjoyment from this submission. It almost sounded like you were watching a movie or playing a game and you held a mic up to the television screen to pick up the song. I'm not saying you stole it I was just trying to explain how the quality sounded.

Not taking the quality into consideration the song sounded really good. It sounds like something that I actually would really enjoy a lot as I am a heavy metal fan. There was probably some room for vocals, but I wouldn't even think about adding them until the quality was better.

The song does get a little repetitive, but not terrible as it seemed to have enough variety to keep it going. All around decent submission if it wasn't for the quality. :P

~ Review Request Club ~

[SN | Once Again | SN]

~ Review Request Club ~

This song had a lot of energy in it and was definitely something that you could dance to or at least tap your foot to or something of the sort. It was a very happy/fun song and would probably go good with any visual such as a happy scene in a movie or game.

I liked the use of vocals here, but they really did add a lot to the submission and I wouldn't mind hearing a little bit more of them added to the submission. Other than that I really can't think of anyway to improve it.

~ Review Request Club ~

SessileNomad responds:

ive been thinking about going "all out" with the vocals and doing like a track where the vocals are the lead, but i would have to write lyrics, sing on time plus make another track

thanks for the review, although this sorta track probly wont be dont again by me for a while

[Windows Wars]

~ Review Request Club ~

Well you've gotten nothing but 10's so the mean spirited person inside of me wanted to give it a 9 so your perfect rating was ruined. :P

Ha, couldn't do it after listening to the song though. The song (even though I think I said this on your last windows song) was probably the best windows song that I have heard on this site even though I've heard quite a few.

The variety and just pure fun that this song contained made it so enjoyable to listen to. The title of "War" gave it a interesting theme as well as now you can almost envision a war going on with these sounds along with it.

~ Review Request Club ~

Step responds:

Ah, how evil XP. I'm expecting Coop to ruin it though, it's hard to get a 10 out of him :P. You did say that on my last windows song, I guess the only genre I'm good at so far (I tried DnB, Classical, Rock, Heavy Metal, Hip-Hop, Jazz and Dance...) is Windows :P. I guess some people like the variety and some people don't. What I think I'll do is invent a catchy main melody which plays once in each windows version, each time with the sound effects that match with the version (E.G.: I did the main melody somewhere in the middle of Windows 2000 with Windows 2000 sound effects, then I did the same melody with Windows XP except with XP's sound effects, etc.), since TBH this is a bit too vared... Anyway, thanks for the great review, and for maintaining my perfect 10 rating :D.