Fro's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[SRD - The Almighty Sterling]

Damn static :P

Great build up effect during the song and pretty good variety throughout the entire thing. The static wasn't too bad in this one, but it still took away from the song a little bit. If the song was cleaned up perhaps it would be something good to use during the credits of a flash submission. A pretty good song to listen to though other than that noise.
Overall - Another good song that is only flawed by the static noise. So I know that you can make great audio. Good job and keep up the good work. (Try to get rid of the static in the future if you can, if you can't then I understand)

~ Review Request Club ~

thegreatmorph responds:

Yeah, I hate it too :(

Thanks again though, all of your reviews are vey much appreciated.

[Heal - Classical Remix]

Great job!

Awesome job all around. I really enjoyed listening to this song. It never really got too repetitive or boring. The entire thing was really fun to listen to. I could see this being used during the introduction of a flash submission. Perhaps something like the older times with knights, kings, wars, etc... It would be very useful for something like that.

Overall - I really don't think there is anything you could do to improve this song. It's really well done all around. Great job and keep up the good work.

~ Review Request Club ~

TheBellmaker responds:

No suggestions :(.... It's ok. When I get the point where all of my songs are like that, then I'll be happy. I have yet to have one of my songs used in a flash though :(. Thanks for listening!

[SRD - Commutersville]

Not bad.

I think in the beginning that perhaps the background music was a little drowned out by the main music. I know you don't want the background stuff too loud, but I think it could have been just a little bit louder. I wish I could give you a higher score because this submission had decent variety in it and a good beat. (For what I could tell) But the static itself made it hard for me to tell for sure.

Giving you the benefit of the doubt I will give the submission a 7. I understand that sometimes things don't turn out as well as they should and this is one of those examples with the static noise.

Overall - Hopefully you can get the whole static thing fixed sometime because the song would probably be much better to listen to. Good luck on any future submissions.

~ Review Request Club ~

thegreatmorph responds:

yeah, i'll definately try to adress the static, believe me it annoys me more than anyone :3

thanks again!

[SRD - Window Shopper]

Not bad.

I thought it was very simplistic, perhaps a little bit too much though. I thought after awhile the song got very repetitive. It was a nice beat though and it was a pretty good song to listen to. I think perhaps it's something that would be pretty good to use over an introduction or maybe even the credits of a flash submission. Probably not so much as in a flash animation itself, but probably during the intro/credits.

Overall - Perhaps it needs a little bit more variety, but what you had was done well and might be useful in a flash some way. Good job and keep up the good work. Good luck on any future submissions.

~ Review Request Club ~

thegreatmorph responds:

Thanks, I try, but there's always room for improvement, and your advice will be not go un noticed :)

[Mind Crushing]

Rock on man.

Yeah, this was pretty good. I have to say I can't wait to hear a version with vocals. I'm commanding you to get someone to put vocals on this. ;) Ha, I would, but that would make this complete shit since I can't sing or anything. The guitar and the drums were awesome during the entire thing. Loved how fast and hardcore the entire thing was. I added it right to my favorites.

If you happen to get someone to put vocals on this please do me a favor and send me a PM. Keep up the good work.

Dimoria responds:

Glad to hear it ;) Ofcourse man. I'll try to see if I can find someone who will fit for the job. And If we get someone. I'll pm you.
Cheers n beers.

[Number of the Beast]

Not bad.

Blah blah, let's get this part out of the way even though you obviously know. It was really quiet. Even when I turn my speakers up all of the way I have a hard time hearing it. Probably because I have a bad hearing problem and I'm almost deaf in both of my ears, whatever though. I finally got it loud enough by hooking it up to some other speakers. Pretty good voice acting voice in my opinion. I can't really see too much wrong with it at all. It was clear and crisp (when I got it loud enough to hear) Perhaps add the words in your author comments or something so people that are having problems hearing can make more sense of it if they can read along.

~ Review Request Club ~

Coop responds:

Edited the comments, as per your suggestion - thanks for the input :)

[Skela-New_years_euphoria]

Not bad

Nice song, overall with some potential in my opinion. It has potential but you still need to work on the production, especially on the EQs. First the guitar in the intro used too much high frequencies and it hurt my ears a bit :P. Also the kick was too loud and over compressed and flooded the other instruments. Other than that, the melody was nice and the chord progression decent. Another thing, in the intro the guitars sounded very weird, as you increased the tempo of a sample, it caused some pitch imperfections, do you get what I mean? Well done, overall.

~ Review Request Club ~

Skela responds:

I guess we all have different taste.
The guitars pitch sounds fine to me, and the kick is suppose to overdub the song.
Anyways,
Thanks for the review.

[MH16: Epic Experiment]

Well composed and arranged

I can see the amount of work and experience with orchestral programs behind the unfinished track, really. The different strings sections were well arranged together and the strings you used sounded quite realistic. The other instruments fitted well the strings as well. Overall, a nice classical song but still unfinished so I can't give it a 10 :P. Too bad you won't finish it.

~ Review Request Club ~

FairSquare responds:

Experience? Me? :P
I barely created songs for like 4 months now.
But thanks for the compliment and the review :-)

MH16

[8-bit war]

Not too bad

Well, it's a bit better than the first loop I reviewed, so a good point for you. The melody was more interesting and used more notes, I can see another improvement here. Though, I noticed that the drums and the melody were not well synchronized, did you play the instruments yourself through a Midi Keyboard? The melody sounded a bit muffled also, try to add some high frequencies to make it brighter.

~ Review Request Club ~

mikkim responds:

and I said not to mention the drums and melodies being out of sync.

[A dance song for Xmas]

Thanks for the present but ...

Put more effort on your song next time. There was no structure and it was overall very messy. There was only one note and not even a chord, also the bit was random and it gets annoying at the first listen. And as Haggard said, it doesn't loop well, so work on it please.

~ Review Request Club ~

mikkim responds:

Haggard said it DOES loop well, not DOESN'T