Fro's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[§-Save Me-§]

Good job.

I thought that the author comments you had to describe the song were very interesting as it's probably not what I would have thought of while listening to this song, but the further it got into the song the more I guess I could see imagining the situation. The song was pretty good and it had a pretty cheerful mood to it, which was the original reason why I was confused why this would be about someone in the need of being saved, but then I thought about what the music may sound like if the person had been given a helping hand and what their mood would then be like. I didn't mind the abrupt ending at the end of the song. It could of had a bit of work, but it didn't hurt the submission too much. Maybe you could of used a fade out or something like a sequence that just sounded good towards the end of the song, which ended on a final note.

C52

~ Review Request Club ~

SinZLazTWordZ responds:

Thanks for the review... And yes you have to listen to it and read what i said to understand fully... Im not starting the chain here in this song but merely passing it along to another person. So instead of making it sound like a fairly gloomy song that goes toward the happier side of life i decided to make it where someone has already been helped and is now helping another person and even though he cant be helped anymore he is still having his fun helping other people move toward there goals!!

~§in§

[(_RGH_) High(Way)]

Pretty good man.

I loved the way it started out with the piano, but I do think the guitar needed to be just a bit louder. The guitar does give the song kind of a dark feeling though, which makes the song interesting because it's not what I would of saw the song being when I first started listening to it. Lyrics might be pretty cool on the song. I don't think they are needed, but they wouldn't hurt either. So if you do put some lyrics on them make sure to check back in with the Review Request Club so we can check it out.

C52

~ Review Request Club ~

RyeGuyHead responds:

yay will do

[(_RGH_) Loco(Motion)]

Pretty cool.

I really liked the introduction of your song and I thought that the song might be pretty good in the background of a flash, but preferably a flash game. The only thing that I think you could of really improved on was the ending of the song. I think something like a fade out or even a series of notes to finish the song off would of been better fitting as it seemed that your song just ended in the middle of a couple of notes. Other then that I really didn't find anything wrong with your audio.

C52

~ Review Request Club ~

RyeGuyHead responds:

I was sort of trying to get it to loop

now it just serves as an intro to Abyss(Dark Pico)

[[SD] Strollin']

Pretty good.

I liked the song. It was a easy song to listen to, which is very important around this time with my headache. >.< The build up really made this song as the song build up to different parts as it went on and overall it was a very cheerful song, which went along nicely with your little comment in your author comments of "Peace, happiness, living the good life." I also like the title Strollin' because it makes me think of someone just strolling along on a nice sunny day with not a care in the world. Good job.

C52

~ Review Request Club ~

SupraDarky responds:

Ahhh yes, that's exactly what I was going for! Someone just strolling around, exactly as you said it! Thanks for the review Corky52, glad you liked it!

[>Gods at Play<]

Very nice.

I let this play through a couple of times before I started to review it so I could get a good hear for it. You did a very good job and I thought the entire audio submission was done very well. The addition of the child's laughter and the man laughter was an interesting addition to the song. The song almost had a dark feeling to it.

C52

~ Review Request Club ~

DjCompass responds:

I'm glad you liked it.
It was in a minor key, and that tends to lend a feel of darkness. Usually...

[Deep Space (DjD)]

Hmm, I liked it.

I think this would be a perfect selection to go along with a horror type film. I can just see the main character entering a very dark cavern or something else of the sort with music like this playing in the background. Great audio for a flash and I hope it gets used sometime in the future. The ending was a bit weird, but pretty cool and I did like the way it faded out towards the end. Good job overall.

C52

~ Review Request Club ~

Mad-Muppet responds:

The ending was supposed to be weird, hehe. Glad you liked it!

[Oboe.Classical.No.1]

Pretty good.

You almost made it so it would loop nicely. I know that this is a song and not a loop, but if it was a loop I could really see this being used as the background music in an old fashion RPG game. Just listening to it makes me think about the old RPG games like final fantasy and legend of dragoons. Ah, those were the days. Anyway the song was nicely down and the length was actually pretty decent because of my opinion on the way it would fir on a RPG game.

C52

~ Review Request Club ~

[Sarah (S. C.)]

Good.

The vocals were done really nice and was obviously the main point of the song, but at the same time the guitar wasn't too bad in itself. Some good humor here, but at the same time it was a pretty good song. You had a decent little solo part there, but I was hoping for something just a bit faster I think. The abrupt ending was actually pretty fitting to the song. Overall, a pretty good job.

C52

~ Review Request Club ~

BreakingFaces responds:

Thanks

[Tiesto Killed The Techno Star]

Pretty good.

I was hoping for a bit more of an evil song here. :( It started off like it was going to be evil and heavy, but after that it just.. wasn't. Oh well, the entire thing was still pretty good! I think that this would be a great song for a flash movie or for a RPG type game perhaps during an exciting battle or exciting part of the game. Pretty decent submission with good length in the song. Keep up the good work.

C52

~ Review Request Club ~

SolusLunes responds:

Yeah, I can see the evil that you're talking about, but that just wasn't a direction I was thinking of at the time. :D

[Quick Shot]

Not too bad.

By reading your author comments I have noticed that this is more of a test then anything. Then I assume that the way it ended wasn't the way that the full version is going to end? I hope not because it almost ended in the middle of a beat and it did end abruptly, but again I will give you the benefit of the doubt that this was just because that it's a test. It may have been a bit repetitive, but the submissions wasn't too long so it didn't really make it bad in this case. If this is just a test then I think you have something to work off from here and that you should keep working on it.

C52

~ Review Request Club ~

jxl180 responds:

Thanks for the review. Yes, this was just a test to see what my various new drum sounds sounded like. So I threw this together real fast, but didn't feel like continuing it. I uploaded it as a loop, but when I listened to it once it was finished uploading, it didn't loop the way I expected it to. So I went into the song properties and changed it from loop to song. But I think I just may finish this.

Thank you,
jxl180