Fro's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Going Downtown]

Pretty good.

This song had a lot of good things. It had great variety because I never knew quite what was coming, which also means it never got boring. It also had a lot of interesting sounds that you don't hear that often when listening to audio. The song itself was really original, which is always a good plus. Perhaps you could have ended the song on a series of notes instead of the small fade out you used. Other than that I think it sounded completely fine.

Overall - A very catchy song, which is pretty fun to listen to. Good job all around and keep up the good work.

~ Review Request Club ~

itsameyayo responds:

Thanks, I will definitely do that! Hopefully, going to music college will expand my creativity :D

-ImperfectDisciple

[MH16: Shooting The Stars]

Good

Score with 18 votes: 4.09

I like to 5 bomb audio submissions because I know a lot of people 0 bomb them. :)

The song itself was pretty catchy. I didn't really think of shooting stars to be exact, but it did remind me of the "older times". Something like a kingdom with knights, kings, etc... I don't know why it just did. The song had a little bit of variety and never really got boring or anything like that. It's an all around good song.

Overall - A nice catchy tune.

~ Review Request Club ~

FairSquare responds:

Thanks! :-)
The title just came to me, i don't know why :P

MH16

[Einsamer Soldat{^}-{Alix1}-{^}]

Hmm

I'm seeing a very obvious occurrence with your songs so far. They are all very repetitive. I don't know if it's because your trying to make them too long or what it is. You may say that the poem has nothing to do with the song, but it's really not a bad mix. I think even just reading the poem in a sad voice while the music is playing might be a pretty decent mix. Maybe you should try playing around with vocals with this song and it may not be so noticeable with how repetitive it is. Also, the sound that happened right at the end of the song made me cring. :(

Overall - I wouldn't mind seeing how this would turn out with some simple vocals.

~ Review Request Club ~

alix1 responds:

That is a good idea but i sing just as well as a whale just huffed some helium ( Just not as high pitched) Thanks for the review!

[Iced Tea Baby! {^}-{alix1}-{^}]

Much better than your other

This is much better than your other submission that I reviewed, but it was still pretty repetitive. The only thing was that you did mix this up a little bit, giving it some different sounds. It was actually quite catchy and I enjoyed listening to it. I even let it play two times through while I did some stuff around the room. Also very original in my opinion.

(Tell your girlfriend she came up with an interesting title. Actually not too bad for the song.)

Overall - Kind of repetitive, but very catchy and overall a fun song to listen to.

~ Review Request Club ~

alix1 responds:

Thanks for the review!

[xD {^}-{Alix1}-{^}]

Hmmm

I liked the start up effect that you had at the beginning of your song, but after that to be honest it got quite repetitive. Anywhere from around 1:35 in the song and on wasn't too different at all. I think the song would have been much better if from 1:35 on you would have worked on the variety of the song. Also, around 2:00 it got extremely repetitive. Even more than it did earlier in the song. I recommend adding some more variety throughout the last half of the song. Perhaps add some cool sound effects or something else like that.

Overall - Very repetitive. Needs to have more variety because it can get boring rather fast. Also, kind of generic.

~ Review Request Club ~

alix1 responds:

oh.. I'm sorry for the repitiveness. This is just how I learned my musics.

[): R.I.P Corky52 :(]

:[ :( ;_;

Such a sad song. Poor guy... must have been a terrible way to go. :(

The song was good. I liked the way it started off really slow and sad and then picked up just to slow down again. When listening to this song I imagine the following scene.

"People are at a funeral all crying and being sad.. slowly the camera zooms towards the head of a person as the scene fades out. When the song gets faster it's that person thinking of all the good/fun times that they had together when the person was alive. The race through his mind and scene after scene makes the person smile while he's still crying. When the song slows back down and counts down the person realizes again that the person is still dead and becomes sad again."

Now you could even go on with a little humor to this and make it into a flash submission, which I plan on doing in the future. The flash will just be like what I explained with a couple of people from newgrounds being there and then at the end when the song is over I'll walk in and be like..., "Man who died?"

Of course I can joke about it now, but I was obviously upset when I found out that it happened. Anyway, I plan on downloading this and using it in a flash so you should keep it up so I can credit you when the flash is submitted in the future.

Thanks for caring enough to make a song man.

Bloodman101 responds:

Sweet! Thanks for the review, Corky52... Or at least his ghost!

Thanks for the Ten.

[Jxl180 - Distorted Dreams]

Not bad.

I enjoyed the introduction to the song and liked the nice little build up that you had. Kind of your generic trance song, but I guess they all are. The whole song did have a very dreamy sound to it so good job on fitting the song with the topic/title. It had a nice catchy beat to it and it was fun to listen to.

Overall - Perhaps a little generic, but I usually have the same feelings for every trance and every techno song that I listen to. :/ Still a fun song to listen to and pretty catchy.

~ Review Request Club ~

jxl180 responds:

I appreciate all the reviews you have written for my songs.

Thank you.

[express]

Not too bad.

I also noticed that at times the guitar was just a little sloppy, but my overall opinion on it was that it sounded pretty good. I don't think I really liked the "sliding" noise that you made with the guitar though. The song itself was pretty good and it was definitely worth a listen. I thought it had decent variety, beat, tune, etc...

Overall - Overall a pretty good song to listen to with a few things that I wouldn't say fit exactly, but still not bad.

~ Review Request Club ~

NeverHundred responds:

Yeah, it's pretty here than there kind of. The part with the sliding was a little off because I slid the guitar pick from the head down two the frets where I sort of did a hammer down on the E and A strings... I liked the sound but it playing it right was a little difficult... but than it goes from that dark kind of atmosphere to a more upbeat light tone, which for me is typical wild and crazy spontaneous fun... but usually other people like songs to be more consistent than that.

[Natural State]

Pretty good.

The beginning of the song was sort of video game like and then it reminded me more of a space like song or at least it gave off that space like feeling of just floating around and everything. I like the build up effect that you used in the beginning of the song. The song had a lot of variety and never got too repetitive. Perhaps it could be something useful in the credits of a flash submission.

Overall - A pretty good song that is worth a listen. Pretty relaxing and it uses nice build up effects.

~ Review Request Club ~

jxl180 responds:

Thanks for the sweet review!

[Jxl180 - Throw Down]

First Review :)

I thought it was sort of interesting, but you can really tell that you rushed on this one. Throughout the entire thing a lot of sounds just sounded like they didn't really belong that much. Also, throughout a little bit of the song there were a couple of errors that I noticed. The one that stuck out the most to me was somewhere right around the 1 minute mark of the song.

Overall - A lot of interesting and great sounds in this song, but for the most part I don't think they really fit well together or at least they didn't fit that well the way that you had them.

~ Review Request Club ~

jxl180 responds:

I did put this together very fast.

Thank you,
jxl180